diff --git a/JoyKit/ControllerConfiguration.inc b/JoyKit/ControllerConfiguration.inc
index cf327f9..6c81e9f 100644
--- a/JoyKit/ControllerConfiguration.inc
+++ b/JoyKit/ControllerConfiguration.inc
@@ -126,14 +126,14 @@ hacksByName = @{
         JOYSubElementStructs: @{
             
             // Rumble
-            @(1364): @[
+            @(1357): @[
                 @{@"reportID": @(1), @"size":@1, @"offset":@0, @"usagePage":@(0xFF00), @"usage":@1, @"min": @0, @"max": @1},
                 @{@"reportID": @(2), @"size":@1, @"offset":@1, @"usagePage":@(0xFF00), @"usage":@1, @"min": @0, @"max": @1},
                 @{@"reportID": @(3), @"size":@1, @"offset":@2, @"usagePage":@(0xFF00), @"usage":@1, @"min": @0, @"max": @1},
                 @{@"reportID": @(4), @"size":@1, @"offset":@3, @"usagePage":@(0xFF00), @"usage":@1, @"min": @0, @"max": @1},
             ],
             
-            @(11): @[
+            @(4): @[
             
             // Player 1
             
diff --git a/JoyKit/JOYAxes2D.m b/JoyKit/JOYAxes2D.m
index 624ccef..a1b91d2 100644
--- a/JoyKit/JOYAxes2D.m
+++ b/JoyKit/JOYAxes2D.m
@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@
 
 - (uint64_t)uniqueID
 {
-    return _element1.uniqueID;
+    return _element1.persistentUniqueID;
 }
 
 - (NSString *)description
diff --git a/JoyKit/JOYAxis.m b/JoyKit/JOYAxis.m
index 169eaee..74a4563 100644
--- a/JoyKit/JOYAxis.m
+++ b/JoyKit/JOYAxis.m
@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@
 
 - (uint64_t)uniqueID
 {
-    return _element.uniqueID;
+    return _element.persistentUniqueID;
 }
 
 - (NSString *)description
diff --git a/JoyKit/JOYButton.m b/JoyKit/JOYButton.m
index 3e6026d..a904299 100644
--- a/JoyKit/JOYButton.m
+++ b/JoyKit/JOYButton.m
@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@
 
 - (uint64_t)uniqueID
 {
-    return _element.uniqueID;
+    return _element.persistentUniqueID;
 }
 
 - (NSString *)description
diff --git a/JoyKit/JOYController.m b/JoyKit/JOYController.m
index b4810ab..10ec6e4 100644
--- a/JoyKit/JOYController.m
+++ b/JoyKit/JOYController.m
@@ -173,13 +173,17 @@ typedef struct __attribute__((packed)) {
 
     JOYElement *previousAxisElement = nil;
     id previous = nil;
+    unsigned persistentUniqueID = 0;
     for (id _element in array) {
         if (_element == previous) continue; // Some elements are reported twice for some reason
         previous = _element;
         NSArray *elements = nil;
         JOYElement *element = [[JOYElement alloc] initWithElement:(__bridge IOHIDElementRef)_element];
+        /* Cookie is not persistent across macOS versions because Apple added kIOHIDElementTypeInput_NULL
+           in a backwards incompatible manner. We must maintain our own cookie-like ID. */
+        element.persistentUniqueID = persistentUniqueID++;
         
-        NSArray<NSDictionary <NSString *,NSNumber *>*> *subElementDefs = hacks[JOYSubElementStructs][@(element.uniqueID)];
+        NSArray<NSDictionary <NSString *,NSNumber *>*> *subElementDefs = hacks[JOYSubElementStructs][@(element.persistentUniqueID)];
 
         bool isOutput = false;
         if (subElementDefs && element.uniqueID != element.parentID) {
diff --git a/JoyKit/JOYElement.h b/JoyKit/JOYElement.h
index 860c247..4a6c311 100644
--- a/JoyKit/JOYElement.h
+++ b/JoyKit/JOYElement.h
@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@
 @property (readonly) uint16_t usage;
 @property (readonly) uint16_t usagePage;
 @property (readonly) uint32_t uniqueID;
+@property unsigned persistentUniqueID;
 @property int32_t min;
 @property int32_t max;
 @property (readonly) int32_t reportID;
diff --git a/JoyKit/JOYSubElement.m b/JoyKit/JOYSubElement.m
index 55e289e..01b121a 100644
--- a/JoyKit/JOYSubElement.m
+++ b/JoyKit/JOYSubElement.m
@@ -34,6 +34,7 @@
         _usage = usage;
         _usagePage = usagePage;
         _uniqueID = (uint32_t)((_parent.uniqueID << 16) | offset);
+        self.persistentUniqueID = (uint32_t)((_parent.persistentUniqueID << 16) | offset);
         _min = min;
         _max = max;
         _reportID = _parent.reportID;